The European Central Bank (ECB) review of internal models TRIM, is a project to assess whether the internal models currently used by banks comply with regulatory requirements, and whether they are reliable and comparable. Banks sometimes use internal models to determine their Pillar 1 own funds requirements, i.e. the minimum amount of capital they must hold by law. TRIM was launched in late 2015 and is expected to be finalised in 2019. This underscores the ECB’s desire to safeguard internal model use for retail and SME portfolios from the potential imposition of a capital floor.
ECB Banking Supervision is making a large investment in TRIM in terms of its own staff as well as the cost of external resources. With regards to staff, close to 100 ECB and national supervisors will be involved.
The targeted review of internal models, or TRIM, is a project to assess whether the internal models currently used by banks comply with regulatory requirements, and whether they are reliable and comparable. Banks sometimes use internal models to determine their Pillar 1 own funds requirements, i.e. the minimum amount of capital they must hold by law.
One major objective of TRIM is to reduce inconsistencies and unwarranted variability when banks use internal models to calculate their risk-weighted assets (RWAs). This may occur because the current regulatory framework gives banks a certain freedom when modelling their risks.
TRIM also seeks to harmonise practices in relation to specific topics. As a result, the review should help to ensure that internal models are being used appropriately.
Thus, the objectives for TRIM coincide with two major goals of ECB Banking Supervision: to foster a sound and resilient banking system through proactive and tough supervision and to create a level playing field by harmonising supervisory practices across the euro area.
This signals the EU’s determination to restore market confidence in banks’ use of internal models to calculate capital requirements, Fitch Ratings says. It may indicate a desire by the ECB to safeguard internal model use for retail and SME portfolios from the potential imposition of a capital floor.
For the eurozone, whose lawmakers and regulators mostly support the use of internal models and the risk-weighting framework for banks, TRIM is important to their argument that internal models make sense for certain portfolios. The ECB hopes to iron out unwarranted variability between models and restore credibility to the use of internal models, at least for “high-default” portfolios where there is sufficient default data for good-quality modelling.
The ECB’s large investment in TRIM suggests that internal models will continue to play an important role in how eurozone banks compute their regulatory capital requirements. TRIM’s focus on retail and SME credit risk may reveal where the ECB’s focus is for discussions on international bank regulation. The EU may be prepared to lose the use of internal models for “low-default” portfolios, such as financial institutions and large corporates, where it is more of a challenge to model statistically robust estimates for unexpected losses.
TRIM seeks to reduce inconsistencies and unwarranted variability when banks use internal models to calculate their risk-weighted assets (RWAs), by harmonising bank and national supervisory practices relating to models. The ECB has issued a 150-page guide allowing banks to assess themselves against common standards and prepare for the scrutiny to come. TRIM is the biggest single investment made by the ECB in supervision since it started in November 2014. The ECB will lead more than 100 reviews in 2017, involving more than 600 people, at 68 eurozone banks, covering approved internal models for credit, market and counterparty credit risks.
TRIM will take place in 2017 and 2018 with a possible extension into the following year. The ECB will ask banks to put right any shortcomings based on the final version of the guide. We expect the ECB to take a harsher stance with tighter timelines for shortcomings due to the banks’ own practices, while allowing more time to adjust for changes from national standards applied by supervisors in the past. Banks are likely to start work this year on aligning their models with the ECB’s standards. This may lead to movements in RWAs from model changes in 2017-2018, before TRIM is completed in 2019.
Disclosure of RWA movements due to model changes would provide helpful insight to analysts, creditors and investors. These market participants will need to be convinced of the TRIM process if the ECB is to remove their scepticism of RWA calculations based on internal models, in our view.